| 1980 | Bartow Rainey | Hammerhead IV |
| 1981 | John Crooks | Great Scott |
| 1982 | Joe Munson | Salt Shaker |
| 1983 | Sam Jennings | J.C. |
| 1984 | Bob Hammersla | Jac-Lyn-Two |
| 1985 | Joe Spadafora | Lady M |
| 1986 | Joe Russo | Scalper |
| 1987 | Lloyd Rasweiller | Reel Time |
| 1988 | Rus Hensley | Beastmaster |
| 1989 | Gilbert Allenby | Chula Vista |
| 1990 | Jim LaBar | Sandancer |
| 1991 | Doc Austin | Bandit |
| 1992 | Tim Parker | Skid Row |
| 1993 | Jim Carley | Escape Hatch II |
| 1994 | Floyd Messer | The Great White |
| 1995 | Pete Hinds | Quetzal |
| 1996 | Gary Angel | Sea Angel |
| 1997 | Ed Hardin | Abracadabra |
| 1998 | Victor Bertrand | Take Time |
| 1999 | David Cummings | Relentless |
| 2000 | Ray Karosas | In Depth |
| 2001 | Marty Bookstone | Double Eagle |
| 2002 | Kaye Pearson | Showpiece |
| 2003 | Ernie Stallings | Aqua Mist |
| 2004 | Gary Tullius | Black Bart |
| 2005 | Lee Berman | Da Cheeze |
| 2006 | Kaye Pearson | Showpiece |
| 2007 | Jeffrey Atwell | Press Time |
| 2008 | Sidney Sussman | Certifiable |
| 2009 | Johnny Hoy | Hoy Boyz |
This artwork was created by Steve Goione for the 2008 Bacardi Tournament.
It was used for the tee Shirt design and the original artwork was part of the Overall Winners Prize.
It was won by Sidney Sussman on the 'Certifiable'